Macdonald claremont school of theology offers in the homeric epics and the gospel of mark a daring proposal to explain the style and origins of the gospel of mark. It is significant that macdonald tells the reader early in his book that detecting and appreciating the parallels he draws requires patience. Macdonald the homeric epics and the gospel of mark. I analysis of the cypria the cypria was clearly designed to clarify unexplained features of homer s story. Martin, mark edwards, barbara clayon, donald letainer, edwin d.
What is not often remembered, however, is that homer s epics were the basic educational texts of everyone in the ancient world who could write greek and that their stories were widely known and often adapted and imitated by ancient writers. Macdonalds seminal work, however, is the homeric epics and the gospel of mark. He begins by describing the common grecoroman custom of teaching prose composition through mimesis greek or. In the gospels and homer macdonald leads readers through homers iliad and odyssey, highlighting models that the authors of the gospel of mark and lukeacts may have imitated for their. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark goodreads. Review of an incredible new book that must be read by everyone with an interest in christianity. According to the thesis of this book, the author of mark s gospel was not writing history, but.
It is also the case that mark used both homer and ot scripture, e. Since then the proliferation of translations has helped to make them the most important poems of the classical european tradition. The santiaga cult in spain understood that james and john were christianized dioscuri homeric epics p. Even if every argument that macdonald offers is valid, there is still a. Macdonald offers an entirely new view of the new testament gospel of mark. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark christian research.
Macdonalds shocking thesis is that the gospel of mark is a deliberate and conscious antiepic, an inversion of the greek bible of homers iliad and odyssey. Macdonalds shocking thesis is that the gospel of mark is a deliberate and conscious anti epic, an inversion of the greek bible of homer s iliad and odyssey, which in a sense updates and judaizes the outdated heroic values presented by homer, in the figure of a new hero, jesus. In later works, he posits the acts of the apostles, the gospel of mark, and gospel of. Finally, critics of mimesis criticism complain that the proposed imitation of classical greek poetry in mark are more extensive than what one finds in most books mimetic of the epics. Macdonalds shocking thesis is that the gospel of mark is a deliberate and conscious antiepic, an inversion of the greek bible of homers iliad and odyssey, which in a sense updates and judaizes the outdated heroic values presented by homer, in the figure of a new hero, jesus. What the gospel of mark and the odyssey tell us about cultural engagement. Macdonald the homeric epics and the gospel of mark argues. Review of the homeric epics and the gospel of mark by dennis r. From the book the homeric epics and the gospel of mark, we see the highly educated writers of the gospel of mark referenced great literature in the writing of the gospel of mark. Mark is also the single originator of the fabricated jesus of nazareth story.
What is not often remembered, however, is that homers epics were the basic educational texts of everyone in the ancient world who could write greek and that their stories were widely known and often adapted and imitated by ancient writers. Mark was composing a prose antiepic, macdonald says, presenting jesus as a suffering hero modeled after but far superior to traditional greek heroes. Dennis ronald macdonald born 1946 is the john wesley professor of new testament and christian origins at the claremont school of theology in california. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark macdonald. Oct 22, 2014 a lot of people i know would be horrified at the premise of the gospels and homer. Mark was written, not with history in mind, but rather homer s epic the odyssey and thus constructed the life of jesus to mirror and in some cases succeed the trials of the heroic odysseus. Proper right here you ll be able to find also as download the gospel of mark ebook. In the gospels and homer macdonald leads readers through homer s iliad and odyssey, highlighting models that the authors of the gospel of mark and lukeacts may have imitated for their. Per seneca skilled authors were bees that took the best nectar from many blossoms to produce textual honey. Homer, the gospels, gullotta and mythicism humes apprentice. In the scheme envisioned here, the gospel of mark, emulating the homeric epics, may be understood as a transvaluative hypertext of the iliad and odyssey.
The homeric epics and the gospel of mark macdonald, dennis r. From a paper read at the october 14, 2000 meeting of the chicago society for biblical research. Dennis ronald macdonald born 1946 is the john wesley professor of new testament and. Close reading and careful analysis show that mark borrowed extensively from the odyssey and the iliad and that he. Close reading and careful analysis show that mark borrowed extensively from the odyssey and the iliad and that he wanted his readers to recognise the homeric. We shouldnt be surprised to find truth in these pagan epics or in aspects of modern culture.
Mark s aemulatio arises from a desire to provide a christian corrective to the pagan values exemplified in the epics 2. Jesus is the new superior moses and jesus is also superior to odysseus. Dennis ronald macdonald is the author of the homeric epics and the gospel of mark 3. Dennis macdonald, concerning his book, the homeric epics and the gospel of mark 2000. In the homeric epics and the gospel of mark macdonald repeatedly points out that ancient people did see the homeric connections. Some say the gospel of mark is not written before 70. Thus he argues that the gospel of mark, emulating homeric epics, can be understood as transvaluative of the iliad and odyssey. The book the homeric epics and the gospel of mark essay. Homeric epics and mark dennis mcdonalds the homeric epics and the gospel of mark 2000 is a book that was always guaranteed to upset orthodox christian theologians and biblical literalists and fundamentalists everywhere, since its main thesis held that the author of the first gospel used the iliad and the odyssey as literary models. If we are serious about the idea of expanding our horizons with interdisciplinary studies, even those of ancient theatre, there is much that is thoughtprovoking here. According to macdonald, the gospel of mark is a deliberate and conscious anti epic, an inversion of the greek bible of homer s iliad and odyssey, which in a sense updates and judaizes the outdated heroic values presented by. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark dennis ronald. Close reading and careful analysis show that mark borrowed extensively from the odyssey and the iliad and that he wanted his readers to recognize the homeric antecedents in marks story of jesus.
Why are homer s epics and the gospel of mark so similar. Macdonald, the homeric epics and the gospel of mark new haven. The gospel of mark is 16 chapters long, shorter than the other three gospels. The hymns are homeric in the sense that they employ the same epic meterdactylic hexameteras the iliad and odyssey, use many similar formulas and are couched in the same dialect. Close reading and careful analysis show that mark borrowed. All scholars acknowledge marks debt to old testament stories and sayings. What is especially impressive is the vast quantity of cases of direct and indirect borrowing from homer that can be found in mark. Jun 09, 2009 the overwhelming majority of parallels drawn in the homeric epics and the gospel of mark are the product of macdonalds vague generalizations, fertile imagination, and literary manipulations. Pdf austin clines interview with dennis macdonald michael. Macdonald has developed the idea of mimesis criticism, the realization that many ancient authors appropriated language, metaphors, and even narrative structure in alignment with another influence. Its traditional author is man named john mark, a companion of simon peter, who wrote the gospel using peters eyewitness accounts. A unique entry into this field is the homeric epics and the gospel of mark by dennis r. I examine whether the gospel of mark copied from homers epics.
From time to time i encounter the idea that the gospel of mark was in some way related to dramatic performance or greek tragedy. Mark was written, not with history in mind, but rather homers epic the odyssey and thus constructed the life of jesus to mirror and in some cases succeed the trials of the heroic odysseus. Macdonald argues that the gospel writers borrowed from established literary sources to create stories about jesus that readers of the day would find convincing. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark book, 2000. Apr 01, 2002 the homeric epic and the gospel of mark dennis r. Mark s aemulatio arises from a desire to provide a new and improved role model which is superior to the pagan gods and heroes.
It is commonly maintained that the gospel of mark was originally written in greek, and that the final text represents a rather lengthy history of growth. Macdonalds homeric epics and the gospel of mark, a preface. The homeric epic and the gospel of mark, the journal of theological studies, volume 53, issue 1. Macdonald, a professor of new testament and christian origins at the claremont school of theology. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark secular web. One or two would be interesting, several would be significant. The author of the earliest gospel was not writing history, nor was he merely recording. The homeric epics and the gospel of mark christian. Lawson the gospel of mark ebook free of registration rating.
The homeric epics and the gospel of mark by dennis r. Mark likely used contemporary literature, such as the works of josephus for characters such as. The author of the earliest gospel was not writing history, nor was he merely recording tradition, macdonald argues. Macdonald proposes a theory wherein the earliest books of the new testament were responses to the homeric epics, including the gospel of mark and the acts of the apostles. This is an essay inspired by groundbreaking discoveries made by the scholar dennis r. Review by richard carrier of dennis macdonalds the homeric epics and the gospel of mark the following is the conclusion. Of course vespasian and his demon chasing happens shortly before 70. Mark likely used contemporary literature, such as the works of josephus for characters such as john the baptist and pilate. Even if every argument that macdonald offers is valid, there is still a complex of material and arguments the pauline letters, for example that his thesis has no effect upon at all.
What do i think of dennis macdonalds book by yale university press. I examine whether the gospel of mark copied from homer s epics. Download the gospel of mark pdf ebook the gospel of mark the gospel of mark ebook author by russell m. Macdonald the homeric epics and the gospel of mark free ebook download as pdf file. Macdonald offers a new view of the new testament gospel of mark. Nov 12, 2010 what are major themes in mark s gospel.
Dennis ronald macdonald author of the homeric epics and. If evidence can be shown that mark copied from homer, what does this mean. The other gospels are later knockoffs, and embellishments, of the original gospel of mark. Feb 23, 2017 the homeric epics vs the gospel of mark rishasha. The gospels and homer imitations of greek epic in mark and lukeacts. Of course, we cant doubt that mimesis was used in ancient continue reading book plunge. Evelynwhite published by the loeb classical library in 1914.
Close reading and careful analysis show that mark borrowed extensively from the odyssey and the iliad and that he wanted his readers to recognise the homeric antecedents in mark s story of jesus. Peter leithart pointed out that every human work of art reflects, in some way, gods story. Mark was composing a prose antiepic, macdonald says, presenting jesus as a. Bible, new testament, synoptic gospels, mark, grecoroman literature, literature, methods, historical approaches, history, grecoroman period. Macdonald argues that the author of mark consciously emulated homeric epic. English are you wanting to locate the gospel of mark book. Download the gospel of mark pdf ebookthe gospel of mark the gospel of mark ebook author by william barclay the gospel. Homer and greek epic introduction to homeric epic chapter 4.
In the homeric epics and the gospel of mark, i proposed that the evangelist sought to embed traditions about jesus within a narrative that would present. Pdf the homeric epics and the gospel of mark semantic. What the gospel of mark and the odyssey tell us about. Macdonald the homeric epics and the gospel of mark by dennis r. Floyd and a number of other scholars, he arrived at the conclusions. For more than a century attempts have been made to explain the origin of the gospel material and to interpret the space between the related events and the final inscripturation of the contents of the gospel. Its hard to really know how to describe a book like this. The author of the earliest gospel was not writing history, nor was he merely recording tradition, macdonald. Macdonald discussing the homeric epics and the gospel of mark. Macdonald, 9780300080124, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The gospel of mark is the second book in the christian new testament and is one of the four gospels.
1191 354 55 295 1173 146 743 1612 118 291 757 1078 1272 1144 283 346 599 1502 270 700 1249 108 1453 623 1152 781 693 1465 17 1318 1452 213 528 1425 1372 7 947 153 1304 229 1485